The Year-End Paycheck Check: Withholding, 401(k) and HSA Settings to Fix Before December 31

Your W-4, 401(k) deferral and HSA payroll deduction all reset on December 31. Here is how to check each one in two weeks, using the 2026 limits.

The Year-End Paycheck Check: Withholding, 401(k) and HSA Settings to Fix Before December 31

Most people fill in their W-4 once, on the first day at a new job, and never open it again. The form was done in a hurry, the default settings stayed in place, and since then your employer has been taking the same amount out of every paycheck regardless of what changed in your life. November is a good time to look, because you still have a few paychecks left in 2026 to correct anything you find.

This piece covers three settings that decide how much of your pay you actually keep: federal withholding, your 401(k) deferral, and your HSA contributions. Each one has a deadline, and two of them close on December 31.

Withholding: a big refund is an interest-free loan

Check your withholding before anything else.

A large refund feels like a windfall in February, but it means the federal government held your money all year and paid you nothing for the privilege. The goal is a small balance either way. Neither a large refund nor a large bill is what you want.

The IRS Tax Withholding Estimator at irs.gov/W4App does the job. Have your most recent pay stub open, because the year-to-date federal withholding figure is the number the tool needs. It projects your full-year tax against what has already been withheld and tells you whether to expect a refund or a bill. Third-party calculators exist, but the IRS tool uses the same current-year rules your return will.

The estimator assumes your W-4 is accurate. If you have a second job, or a spouse who works, the single-job assumption is wrong. Two-earner households are the usual case where the withholding looks fine on one paycheck and falls short across the year. The estimator asks about other jobs, so answer those questions honestly rather than skipping them.

Re-file a W-4 whenever something material changes. The usual triggers are a raise that moves you into a higher bracket, a second job, marriage or divorce, a new child, or a spouse who starts or stops working. Each of these changes the arithmetic your employer uses, and the form on file was built for the situation you were in on day one. A new W-4 takes a few minutes to complete, and it applies from the first payroll your employer processes after it is submitted. A bonus is a separate case, because employers usually withhold on supplemental pay at a flat rate that does not reflect your full tax position. That means a bonus can be under-withheld for someone in a higher bracket, or over-withheld for someone who will end the year in a lower one. You will not see the difference until you run the estimator, which is one more reason to run it in November rather than in April.

The 401(k): payroll stops at the limit, and you cannot catch up after payroll ends

The 2026 employee deferral limit for 401(k) plans is $24,500, up from $23,500 in 2025, according to the IRS. Deferrals come out of your pay during the calendar year, so the limit is enforced through your paycheck. Once your year-to-date deferrals reach the cap, the plan stops taking more, and whatever you did not defer by your last 2026 payroll is gone for the year.

Here is the arithmetic for a biweekly paycheck schedule, which gives 26 pay periods a year. Someone who wants the full $24,500 needs to defer about $942 from each paycheck ($24,500 divided by 26 is $942.31). If you started the year at a lower percentage, you can raise it now, but only if the remaining paychecks can carry the rest. Divide what you still need by the number of pay dates left, then compare that to your current percentage.

Check the match formula before you change anything. Many employer matches are calculated per paycheck, so a deferral that front-loads the whole limit into the first few months of the year can cost you match money in the months when you have stopped contributing. Some plans true up the match at year-end, which fixes the gap, but many do not, and the plan summary will say which kind yours is. Take a hypothetical plan that matches 50% of the first 6% of pay: a 6% deferral earns a 3% employer match, and a 10% deferral earns no more than that 3%. Read the plan summary or ask HR how the match is calculated before you change the percentage, because the cost of getting this wrong is paid in employer money you never receive. The safe move in a plan without a year-end true-up is to keep the deferral steady enough to receive the match in every pay period.

If you are 50 or older, the catch-up contribution adds to that limit. For 2026 the standard catch-up is $8,000, according to the same IRS release. Higher earners with prior-year FICA wages above the SECURE 2.0 threshold have to make catch-up contributions as Roth starting in 2026, which affects how your plan records them. Ask the plan administrator how your catch-ups will be coded before you assume the tax treatment.

HSA: payroll contributions close on December 31, direct ones do not

The 2026 HSA limits are $4,400 for self-only coverage and $8,750 for family coverage, per IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-19. If you are 55 or older, you can add a $1,000 catch-up.

There are two ways to put money in, and they close on different dates. Payroll contributions through your employer's cafeteria plan have to be made by the last paycheck of 2026. Those contributions skip the 7.65% FICA tax on your wages, which is the reason to route HSA money through payroll rather than transferring it yourself. A direct contribution from your bank account can still be made for 2026 until the federal tax filing deadline, which is normally April 15, 2027.

Use payroll for the HSA. The FICA saving is real money on every dollar you contribute, and a direct transfer gives you nothing extra in return. Take a full $4,400 self-only contribution through payroll and you skip about $337 of employee-side FICA (7.65% of $4,400). That saving is smaller than the contribution itself, but it is money a direct transfer cannot match. Employer contributions to an HSA are a separate line, so confirm with HR whether they follow the same payroll route. The one exception is when your payroll deduction is already at the limit, in which case the direct route is the only way to add more for 2026. Check that payroll and direct contributions together stay within the $4,400 or $8,750 cap for your coverage type. Excess contributions carry a 6% excise tax for each year they stay in the account, unless you withdraw them by the filing deadline.

Confirm with your HR or benefits team whether your cafeteria plan will accept changes after your final paycheck of the year. Some employers close enrollment changes earlier than December 31. A late change that the payroll system cannot process will leave the money in your bank account and the FICA saving lost.

A checklist for the next two weeks

  • Pull your most recent pay stub and copy the year-to-date federal withholding figure.
  • Run the IRS Withholding Estimator at irs.gov/W4App and compare the projected refund or bill with your target.
  • Check your 401(k) year-to-date deferral against the $24,500 limit and calculate the per-paycheck amount needed to finish the year at the cap.
  • Read your plan's match formula before changing the deferral percentage.
  • Ask HR for the last date you can change your HSA payroll deduction and whether the cafeteria plan accepts changes after that date.

Do the withholding check first. It takes about ten minutes, and it is the one item on this list that changes your tax bill for 2026 rather than your savings. The 401(k) and HSA settings matter too, but they matter most in the last two pay periods, when a mistake can no longer be fixed.

The last payroll of the year is the cheapest place to correct a setting that has been wrong for twelve months. Use it, and do not wait for January to find out what the settings cost you.